Tyler Reddick’s win in the Southern 500, which clinched the regular-season championship by a narrow margin over Kyle Larson, was overshadowed by an unexpected issue that arose after the race. The controversy stemmed from the absence of a NASCAR executive to present Reddick with his championship trophy, leading to heightened tensions within 23XI Racing, the team co-owned by basketball icon Michael Jordan and NASCAR driver Denny Hamlin.
Hamlin expressed his displeasure candidly, as reported by the Associated Press. He stated, “I’m certainly pretty disappointed that no one from NASCAR was there to present Tyler with his trophy.” This incident comes amidst growing friction between NASCAR and racing teams regarding the extension of the franchise system.
The core of the dispute involves ongoing discussions about the charter system, which secures race entries and a share of television and prize money for 36 charters in the premier Cup Series. Teams are advocating for a larger revenue share and more permanent charters, while NASCAR has suggested adding anti-disparagement clauses and the possibility of repossessing charters to accommodate new manufacturers.
Curtis Polk, another co-owner of 23XI Racing, has been outspoken against these proposals. He once used a sign that read: “Please don’t ask me about my Charter. I don’t want to disparage NASCAR and risk losing it.” The absence of a NASCAR representative at Reddick’s trophy ceremony appears to reflect deeper issues between NASCAR and the teams, highlighting fundamental disagreements over the sport’s future and governance.
Hamlin elaborated on the discord, noting that the current situation pits NASCAR against the teams in a battle for financial resources. “NASCAR owns certain aspects of the sport and teams own others, leading to competition for the same sponsors,” he explained. “They don’t want you to speak negatively about them, which is a new addition to the charter agreement. One side will need to be reasonable for progress to be made.”
He also criticized NASCAR’s resistance to change, reflecting on the sport’s evolution since the early days established by Bill France Sr. “NASCAR has always considered itself the family business, and if you don’t like it, you don’t have to be involved,” Hamlin said. “But times have changed, and while I respect what has been built, there comes a point where you need to adapt or risk holding the sport back.”
This discontent has had practical implications, with teams delaying image rights for a Netflix series amidst ongoing negotiations, thus disrupting potential crossover and promotional opportunities. “In my opinion, until we address these issues, we’ll just be spinning our wheels,” Hamlin commented.
The lack of recognition for the teams’ role in building the sport seems to particularly frustrate Hamlin and others. “It’s more about the lack of acknowledgment that teams have built this sport. Figures like Rick Hendrick and Joe Gibbs have put superstars on the track, which has truly built the sport,” he asserted.
The situation is further complicated by concerns that the sport’s growth is being stifled by outdated practices. “Fans don’t come just to see cars go in circles. If that were the case, ARCA races would sell out. Fans come to see stars like Chase Elliott, Kyle Larson, and Kyle Busch,” Hamlin pointed out.
As teams and NASCAR navigate these contentious issues, particularly with charters set to expire at the end of the year, uncertainties loom. Without resolution, legal and operational challenges could arise by 2025. “Some teams might accept any deal offered, while others, with more business acumen, see the terms as unreasonable,” Hamlin noted.
He concluded with a call for unity, stating, “We end up competing against each other rather than coming together to grow the sport.”