The Indianapolis Colts have hit a rough patch over the past three weeks, losing three straight games and stirring controversy by benching their young quarterback, Anthony Richardson, in favor of veteran Joe Flacco. Head coach Shane Steichen defended the decision, citing Flacco’s “veteran leadership,” but Flacco’s performance has been far from steady, with five interceptions in just two games. A season that started with promise is now on the verge of collapse, leaving fans and former players frustrated and searching for answers.
One of the loudest critics of the Colts’ recent struggles is former Colts player and sports media personality Pat McAfee. After Indianapolis’ 30-20 loss to the Buffalo Bills in Week 10, McAfee didn’t hold back, openly criticizing the team’s direction and lack of support for Richardson. According to McAfee, the current Colts’ setup leaves Richardson without the necessary guidance, and he pointed out that even the team’s leaders, like cornerback Kenny Moore, are publicly questioning the professionalism within the organization.
Kenny Moore’s postgame remarks echoed McAfee’s concerns, sending shockwaves through the team. Moore stated that not everyone seems fully committed, saying, “I don’t think everybody is working as hard as possible, and obviously it’s showing.” This statement speaks to a deeper issue within the Colts organization, one that extends beyond Richardson’s benching and highlights a lack of cohesion and motivation on the roster.
As for Richardson, the young quarterback has struggled in his sophomore season, managing only four touchdowns against seven interceptions, with a concerning 44.4% completion rate. Although the team initially emphasized patience in Richardson’s development, Steichen felt pressure to make a change after the Colts’ record fell to 4-4. But with Flacco’s shaky performances, doubts are growing about whether he’s the answer Indianapolis needs to salvage their season.
Despite the concerns, Steichen has confirmed that Flacco will remain the starter for their upcoming game against the New York Jets. With fans and former players like McAfee openly voicing their frustrations, the Colts are under intense scrutiny. The question now is whether Steichen’s decision to keep Flacco under center can help turn things around, or if Indianapolis is set for more disappointment as their season continues to unravel.
