In 2023, the Detroit Lions faced significant challenges with their pass defense, ranking among the league’s worst. In response, general manager Brad Holmes made strengthening the secondary a priority, which included trading for veteran cornerback Carlton Davis from the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
Although Davis brought some stability to the Lions’ defense, his performance has not met expectations. He allowed a 65.2% completion rate and a passer rating of 99.3. In contrast, rookie Terrion Arnold has been more effective, with a 56.5% completion rate and a passer rating of 91.8.
These statistics suggest that Davis may not be part of Detroit’s future plans, particularly with Arnold emerging as a reliable option and Ennis Rakestraw Jr. waiting for an opportunity. Furthermore, the Lions are unlikely to accommodate Davis’ contract demands, which could lead to the 27-year-old seeking a new team next season.
The Pittsburgh Steelers have been identified as a potential landing spot for Davis, according to Bleacher Report’s Scouting Department. The Steelers boast an emerging star in cornerback Joey Porter Jr., whose development hints at elite potential. However, they lack a strong partner for him, as Donte Jackson, while serviceable, may not be a long-term solution.
Jackson has outperformed Davis in critical areas, allowing just 53.1% of passes completed against him and achieving an impressive passer rating of 31.5. If Jackson maintains this level of play, the Steelers are likely to focus on retaining him. However, if contract negotiations fail, Davis could be a viable backup plan to pair with Porter Jr.
Davis’ experience and adaptability make him an intriguing option for Pittsburgh. His ability to adjust to different defensive schemes has been a notable asset in Detroit, and the Steelers could benefit from utilizing him in a similar role. Despite his struggles with the Lions, Davis’ veteran presence and versatility could address Pittsburgh’s needs in the secondary.
Both Detroit and Pittsburgh are positioned well financially for the offseason. Projections from Over the Cap estimate that the Steelers will have $73.4 million in salary cap space, while the Lions are expected to have $70.1 million. This financial flexibility allows both teams to explore free-agent acquisitions to strengthen their rosters.
The Steelers’ cornerback strategy largely depends on their ability to re-sign Jackson. If they fail to retain him, Davis could emerge as an affordable and suitable replacement. A fresh start with Pittsburgh might provide Davis with an opportunity to rebuild his career while helping solidify the Steelers’ secondary for the 2025 season.
