Former NFL MVP Cam Newton didn’t hold back when he addressed Indianapolis Colts quarterback Anthony Richardson’s controversial decision during Week 8. Frustrated by Richardson’s choice to request a one-play substitution, Newton questioned his dedication to the game.
Richardson, the former No. 4 overall pick, told reporters he was simply “tired” when he asked head coach Shane Steichen to take him out momentarily—a move that raised eyebrows across the NFL.
Newton tackled the issue head-on in the latest episode of his “4thand1” podcast, sending a strong message to Richardson about what it means to be a professional athlete. Reflecting on the young quarterback’s recent performance, Newton vented, “I’m looking at your stats—10 for 32, 175 yards, one touchdown, and a questionable interception.
Bro, what the f—k? You’re a professional. You don’t get to tap out just because you’re tired.” For Newton, this type of mentality separates good players from elite ones, like Lamar Jackson, whose consistency and effort he praised.
Richardson’s controversial request has since led to significant repercussions. Despite Colts head coach Shane Steichen downplaying any link between Richardson’s actions and his subsequent benching, the quarterback was swapped out for veteran Joe Flacco ahead of their game against the Minnesota Vikings. Steichen later announced that Flacco would remain the starter for the rest of the season, citing the team’s need for stability as they aim for a strong finish.
Amid Richardson’s uncertain future, rumors about a potential trade have begun to swirl. The controversy hasn’t only ruffled feathers among fans and analysts; even Colts linebacker Zaire Franklin shared his disappointment in Richardson’s approach. Franklin openly admitted he wished Richardson had simply “lied” about his fatigue, saying, “Help me out, lie like you stole something! Just say you were hurt, anything but ‘I’m tired.’”
The Colts’ recent 23-20 loss to their divisional rivals has only added to the mounting tension, leaving the team with a middling 4-4 record. As speculation about Richardson’s role continues, it remains to be seen whether he’ll regain the trust of his teammates, coaches, and fans—or if his early NFL journey might take an unexpected turn.
